Caramel apples

10 favorite fall treats you can have shipped to your door

Pumpkin dessert

Happy Fall, y’all!

Here at SexyModest, we believe in anything that makes women’s lives better. And while we’re all about healthy nutrition and fitness habits, we love a good treat as much as the next gal. 

Obviously, this means anything pumpkin, caramel, apple, spiced, pumpkin spiced, caramel apple, pumpkin caramel, apple spiced, etc., is on the table… but you really can’t go wrong with any type of treat this time of the year! 

We’ve just taken the liberty of narrowing down the options to our favorite fall treats you can order online for maximum comfort and convenience. So, cozy on up in your favorite sweats and get ready to have some delicious fall goodness delivered directly to your door!

Amy’s Gourmet Caramel Apples

Apple Pie Caramel Apple dunked in white chocolate

Caramel apple lovers, listen up. If you haven’t tried these world famous gourmet caramel apples, get ready for a life-altering experience. (Okay, perhaps that’s a bit of an overstatement… but only slightly.) Amy’s Gourmet Apples have been named the “Best Caramel Apple” by the Wall Street Journal, which is probably why people all over the country order them straight out of Amy’s Wisconsin kitchen. Made from fresh jumbo Granny Smith apples and luxurious hand-made caramel, these caramel apples will take you to a whole new level. Plus, there are plenty of fall favorites to choose from to get you in a festive mood.

Western Nut Popcorn Brittle

Western Nut popcorn brittle

Yum. Yum. Yum, yum, yum. All you have to do is look at the pictures of Western Nut’s popcorn brittle and trust us — you will be salivating. You get your buttery, caramel popcorn mixed with roasted almonds, cashews, peanuts, and pecan halves… It's the perfect blend of sweet and savory. Your sweet tooth will be delighted. Western Nut also has a wide variety of treats and baskets to choose from if you’re looking for some holiday gift ideas.

Reese’s Halloween peanut butter pumpkins

Bag of Reese's pumpkin peanut butter cups

Question: What is the best Halloween candy, hands down? The correct answer is, of course, Reese’s peanut butter cups. (Admit it — you scour your kids’ candy bags in search of that coveted orange wrapper, don’t you?) Well, the only thing that makes a peanut butter cup better is offering it in a pumpkin shape for fall, which is why you’ve definitely got to “treat yo’ self” to these Halloween-themed Reese’s. You can pick these bad boys up at your local grocery store, but if you’re feelin’ lazy (we don’t blame you), you can stay in your pajamas and order them straight from Amazon or Target.

Trader Joe’s pepita salsa

Trader Joe's Pepita Salsa

Trader Joe’s knows a thing or two about tasty treats and fine food, and this pepita salsa is no exception! Don’t be thrown off by the fact that it’s not technically a “treat” per se. (This is the only strictly savory option on the list.) But this is definitely one you’ve got to try. Whoever had the idea to put pumpkin seeds in salsa was a crazy, brilliant genius because it totally works. Seriously, you will be looking for excuses to eat this stuff up. 

*NOTE: Trader Joe’s does not offer delivery, sadly, but you can find this salsa and many of their other products on Amazon.

Trader Joe’s pumpkin and waffle mix

Trader Joe's Pumpkin Pancake and Waffle Mix

Of course we couldn’t just have ONE Trader Joe’s treat on the list here, so here’s another crowd-pleaser for you: their pumpkin and waffle mix. Basically, if you go through October and November without making pumpkin-flavored pancakes or waffles, then you are guilty of a Class C misdemeanor. (That’s a joke — but then again, so is going an entire fall season without pumpkin flavored pancakes and waffles.) Grab yourself one of these mixes on Amazon before they’re all gone!

Harvest Kringle from O&H Bakery

O&H Harvest Kringle

All right, stepping away from the pumpkin craze for just a minute, here’s another treat you’ve got to try: the Harvest Kringle from O&H Bakery. This seasonal favorite out of Wisconsin (yet another treat from Wisconsin!) is only available in September and October, so you'll have to act fast if you want one delivered to your door. Just try to get through this description without drooling: crisp, juicy apples sprinkled with cinnamon and baked with toffee bits. Even if you have no Danish blood in your veins, this kringle will have you exclaiming “lækker!” (Which we hope means “delicious,” if Google translate did its job correctly.)

Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookies from Levain Bakery

Levain Bakery chocolate chip walnut cookies

Though not technically a “fall” treat specifically, the world famous chocolate chip walnut cookies from Levain Bakery are absolutely worthy of a spot on this list. Since it can be difficult to make the trip out to New York to grab one fresh out of the oven, buying them online is your next best option. (There are several copycat recipes out there, but you’ve got to try the real thing!)

Any of these Harry & David gift baskets

Harry & David pumpkin shaped gift basket

This is where we had a little trouble narrowing things down because Harry & David are definitely the kings of food gifts. And fall is where they really shine. Take your pick from their pumpkin-shaped gift basket, their harvest truffles, their meat and cheese samplers, and more. You can even order a deep-dish pumpkin pie. Whew. You may need to loosen that belt, but it’ll be worth it.

Fall assorted truffle box from Milk Bar

Milk Bar fall assorted truffle box

Here’s another fun one that your kids might enjoy, too. Milk Bar is famous for their unique take on cakes and desserts and during the fall season you can also try their limited-time apple cider flavored treats. (Including their apple cider doughnut cake. Mmm….) If you’ve never tried Milk Bar and want to get a good sampling of their best flavors, check out their fall assorted truffle box. You’ll get their cult-favorite birthday cake flavors along with the apple cider doughnut cake bites. Each box comes with six truffles per flavor, so you can share the goodness with your friends and family — or just eat ‘em all yourself. No judgement. 

Perk Chill pumpkin spice

Perk Chill pumpkin spice

Finally, you know we’ve got to talk about one of Brig’s all-time favorite things: Perk Chill. (And yes, ladies, it comes in a pumpkin spice flavor, so let the happy dances commence!) This special blend of pumpkin, nutmeg, cinnamon and vanilla is formulated to help you wind down and relax at the end of a busy day. It includes collagen to support healthy muscles, joints, skin, and hair, as well as a power sleep mineral complex to help you rest easier at night, among several other health benefits. (And did we mention it’s a party for your tastebuds? Because that’s a huge bonus.) Use code modest at checkout to get a discount on your order!

Hopefully, you found something on this list to satisfy your sweet tooth and pumpkin cravings. But if we missed something that should absolutely be on this list, we want to know! Drop your favorite fall treats in the comments. We can’t wait to try them all!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.